early seshnela, kralorela

From: Peter Metcalfe (P.Metcalfe@student.canterbury.ac.nz)
Date: Tue 03 Jun 1997 - 14:32:20 EEST


Joerg Baumgartner:
==================

Me>>The fact that the Basmoli dwell in "cities" means diddley-squat (such
>>hidden information from the Book of Kings BTW can be found in the
>>Genertela Book) with respect to the rest of their technology or level
>>of culture (to wit iron armour and sorcery).

>The source you mentioned states nothing about iron armour on either side,
>and mentions sorcery for both. In fact, the famous sorcerers in this
>conflict all are Pendali...

It's helpful to remember exactly *when* the Book of Kings was
written. At that point in time, the precise, nay even the
general specifics of Malkioni religion had not been sorted out.
A parallel example is Jonat's Saga which Greg says at the back
of Trollpak (RQIII edition) is wrong in that one type of troll
would be now described as a Darkness Spirit. Thus attempts to
prove that the Pendali are a nation of civilized sorcerers are
fatally flawed methinks.

>>For all we know, their
>>level of sophistication would be no better than the Rathori or the
>>Shan Shan Hsunchen. IMO the Basmoli empire was based on the conquest
>>of sedentary peoples and so they lived off the latter's labour.

>As I understand Greg's intentions for the Dawn Age and earlier, this usually
>is not the case. At least I got rebuffed when I suggested a similar theory
>for the Vingkotling entry into Genertela.

But there is evidence for the Basmoli migration and there
is no evidence for a Vingkotling 'migration'. To wit:

        'Ancient Seshnegi documents demonstrate clearly that
        the language spoken by the Hsunchen Basmoli invaders
        of the second century is essentially identical to the
        language spoken by the relic tribes surviving today
        in Ralios and Prax. The noted Jrusteli scholar Dakon
        Ven Dalorin demonstrated in 998 that the Basmoli living
        in Tarien (who may now be extinct) also spoke this same
        language.'

        
                Glorantha Book: Lanuages p34.

(Yes, the chronological points are interesting).

        'In Pamaltela, the Basmoli only know that their god
        marched northwards with a horde of followers, and still
        await a triumphant return'

                Gods of Glorantha p44.

So the Basmoli are one of the exceptions IMO.

>The Pendali are an indigenous culture whose founder - a son of Basmol -
>married the daughter of Seshna Likita, and their children founded the
>Basmoli kingdoms.

Non sequiter. King Froalar also married Seshna Likita and founded
the Serpent Kings Dynasty but nobody would suggest that the Malkioni
are indigenous to Seshnela. Furthermore Lords of Terror (p86) mentions
that an ancient Seshnelan dynasty (extinct before the Dawn) worshipped
Sidana. Since Sidana is a patron of incest which is not AFAIK a
Basmoli practice, it seems to me that the Basmoli supplanted the
Sidanings when they invaded.

>>We know the Pralori similarly 'oppressed' the people of Wenelia at the
>>Dawn.

>You mean the Mraloti hsunchen there?

The Wenelians were Haralding Orlanthi (or at least King Vathmai was).

>>Furthermore
>>back on the Motherland, the Brithini who are even more outmoded
>>than the Dawn Malkioni, have successfully managed to repulse
>>at least two invasions.

>Much later, unless you call the retreat of the glaciers towards the
>Dawn as a successful repulsion of an invasion.

But the Brithini have not changed since the Silence was lifted
thus the 'much later' comment is irrelevant to the original
point.

>>Why should the Basmoli be wearing armour? The True Basmoli needs
>>aught but his skin IMHO.

>The Pendali did wear armour. QED.

This from the Book of Kings again? I don't believe it for
the same reasons mentioned above.

>What you call "True Basmoli" was what the exile people became after being
>pushed out of Tanisor as well.

And somehow degenerated into carbon copies of their lifestyle
before they started to learn sorcery? Surely this would have
started ringing alarm bells?

JB>>>The Six-Legged Empire was doomed as long as it relied solely on its
>>>mounted forces to win their battles, since horses get sick on the
>>>plains of Jolar quickly.

Me>>Um, then how _did_ the six-legged empire manage to conquer the
>>plains in the first place?

>With a ready supply of yet undiseased horses.

Where from? Bear in mind that the Horse start to get sick
as soon as one goes into the Laskal forest. Thus by the
time they get to the plains, they would be next to useless.
IMO the horse sickness is a curse brought about by either
the Doraddi or the Empire of Errinoru.

[Silver Empire]

>Lemmesee. The True Hrestol Way got to power about 150 to 200 ST. The Brithos
>invasion occurred less than 200 years after the civil war in Seshnela had
>subsided. The Seshnela visited by Arkat around 400 was torn in civil war
>between lots of minor kingdoms, Gerlant's being the most prominent.

I don't think there was a civil war - the Serpent Kings died out
and then the True Hrestol Way took over in a violent coup d'etat.
Perhaps the Serpent Kings were killed in the Second Century
Basmoli invasions? We know that the Dangam confederacy expanded
eastwards from the Genertela book so he could have pushed the
(Tanisorian?) Basmoli into the Seshnelan lands.

>The Dari confederation had conquered Tanisor around 265, and held even parts
>of Seshnela until his assassination in 307. In 350 it was resurrected.

>This suggests that the great unified Silver Empire lasted (in Ralios, at
>least) for about 60 years. Sounds very much like the conquests of one
>powerful king, only to be lost by his son when he tried for Brithos.

I presume from the loss of Safelster and Tanisor that the Silver Empire's
forte was primarily naval. This would explain why it managed to hold
onto Akem and plant colonies in Jrustela despite the loss of Tanisor
to Dari. (After all England lost Calais yonks before it became the

Empire on which the Sun never set).

I note that the process of political integration of Malkioni Fronela
begins circa 385 ST (according to Codex 2). Given that when Arkat
lands, Arolanit is composed of City States, I'm inclined to believe
that the disaster of the Brithos expedition took place within ten
years _after_ the Sun Stop and its abject failure lead to the complete
political disintegration of the Silver Empire. Note that Gerlant is
purging other _dynasts_ (and not nobles) of their lands. This fits the
emphasis given to the Silver Empire in the Jrusteli monomyth (p11 Gods
of Glorantha).

James Frusetta:
===============

>Though I actually _do_ like the idea of tossing trollkin in the way of
>missile fire. A fine trollish martial arts skill, IMO, similar to
>arrow catching/deflecting and suitable for wizened troll sensei.

Not really. Why do the Uz play Trollball? Drop kick is all they need.

>but Golden Bow may
>well offer the spell -- meaning that Elves (assuming they worship Golden
>Bow) would have access to (arrrrgh!) a re-usable smart missile spell.

I don't think the Elves worship the Golden Bow cult of the Pentans.
The two hardly ever interact and when they do, it's usually hostile
in nature (ie Skyburn). The elves may know of a bow spirit that
offers similar magic (Tobasta Greenbow springs to mind) but I doubt
that they would worship Golden Bow.

Stephen Martin:
===============

>I beg to differ -- I don't recall the source (Joerg, where's your
>index?), but one published source states that the God Learners took the
>obscure PoIM and expanded it into a larger, more important organization.

Glorantha Book p24

        'Nor did anyone notice immediately the subtle changes
        which occured in Kralorela when the God Learners replaced
        the Ancient Empire with their own version of draconic
        powers by adopting and expanding the previously obscure
        Path of Immanent Mastery'.

[Thang Chow, Emperor of Kralorela]

>>Page 33, illustration sidebar text, I'd say this
>>Thang Chow is rather apocryphal.

>Quite apocryphal, since it was not in the original Wyrms Footnotes
>article by any means, and is nowhere else in print.

I'm surprised by this as I thought that the artwork looked as
though it had been in the original Wyrms Footnotes article.
Might it not have been in the Dragon Pantheon? (Not that I
have access to either).

>Hey, maybe Thang Chow is the
>FDR Emperor, since the consensus seems to be that Shang-hsa (MHNBC) was
>not.

Looking at the Kralorela writeup, I note for the City of Chang
Tsai:

        'In the Second Age, thanks to God Learner meddling, the
        Ogre King and the Legion of Red Bones seized control
        of this city. After the Closing it was liberated by
        Thang How of Fuknama.'

Presuming that it's a mispelling, the suggestion seems quite
probable as after the Closing, the False Dragons Ring was
still in charge of Kralorela for another 150 years. In addition,
the suspiciously God Learner-like rune on his bathrobe would
damn him. Additionally the Kralori writeup implies IMO that the
false Emperor is a native Kralori as they appointed him rather
than selected one of their number to be emperor.

To explain the passage, I think originally the city was held
by conservative Mandarins who refused to acknowlege the authority
of the New Dragons Ring. Being unable to take the city, the
New Dragons Ring conspired via some Huan To intermediaries with
the Ogre King to take the city from behind. After the Closing,
Thang How decided to kick the Ogre King out.

- --Peter Metcalfe

------------------------------

End of Glorantha Digest V4 #459
*******************************

RuneQuest is a trademark of Avalon Hill, and Glorantha is a trademark
of Chaosium. With the exception of previously copyrighted material,
unless specified otherwise all text in this digest is copyright by the
author or authors, with rights granted to copy for personal use, to
excerpt in reviews and replies, and to archive unchanged for
electronic retrieval.

Send electronic mail to Majordomo@erzo.org with "help" in the body of
the message for subscription information on this and other mailing
lists.

WWW at http://rider.wharton.upenn.edu/~loren/rolegame.html


This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.7 : Fri 13 Jun 2003 - 17:00:39 EEST