From: Joerg Baumgartner (
Date: Tue 24 Feb 1998 - 14:25:15 EET

Richard Develyn wondered

> RQ2 had a section on Alchemists Guild, Free Sages, Thieve's Guild,
> Horsemasters Guild, and so on. RQ3 doesnt. What is the situation with
> guilds in Glorantha? In particular, I'm interested in Alchemists

My take on this is three-fold:

1) These guilds were in large part to give previous experience. RQ3 has
different approach to this, so the guilds weren't needed.

2) The Sartarite cities are in fact much smaller than was implied in
and these extensive guilds probably don't exist in most cities. In
particular, I wouldn't expect Thieves Guilds in most of the cities on
RQ2 map -- the cities simply aren't big enough to warrant an
of thieves (to say anything about even a handful of full-time thieves).
few cities, such as Jonstown or Boldhome, might have rudimentary guild
structures. (And huge ones like Nochet certainly would.)

3) Alchemists in particular didn't really make RQ2 more fun. You'd get
dreadfully boring Blade Venom or other poisons.

I suppose there's also

4) RQ3 is generic, and guilds aren't.

So I think guilds were dropped as being not too typical of Glorantha
certainly not Sartar or Prax), and hardly a standard model for a generic

Joerg Baumgartner (via Hotmail)

Get Your Private, Free Email at


This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.7 : Fri 13 Jun 2003 - 23:12:30 EEST