From: David Dunham (dunham@pensee.com)
Date: Tue 09 Jun 1998 - 00:31:45 EEST
Jane Williams wondered about
> Six Sisters Hills. One of the hills is noted as being that of the bee-
> headed sister. Any ideas where these are?
Surely it's the Six Sisters in Battle Valley (see The Haunted Ruins -- the
George Harris averred
> A simulationist is someone that
I'm not going to discuss your definition per se, but I will jump in with a
Hero Wars represents a paradigm shift for most of us.
Until now, most RPGs have been simulationist. They attempt to model the
Hero Wars also models the real world, but by simulating its outcomes. A die
trolls call them the Six Hags). (I'm not sure which one is bee-headed.
These are also special hills to the Grazers, I believe.
> prefers for a roleplaying world to act in a consistent manner, with the
> various characters acting as actual humans (or whatever) would, and
> resolutions be made solely with regard to what is the most likely outcome,
> rather than what best suits the story, say.
comment as the term relates to Hero Wars.
real (or imaginary) world by simulating its processes. For example, RQ
models combat by rules for the process of making an attack and the process
of thwarting that attack. Each die roll generally simulates some
easily-identifiable real world event or process. You may not agree that
it's the best simulation, but the mapping is clear.
roll in Hero Wars probably doesn't directly represent some real world event
- -- notably rolls in combat. Advantage ebbs and flows, and only after the
combat is over do you know the outcome. A winning die roll doesn't
necessarily equate to a well-swung sword. But combat is still modelled -- a
good warrior is more likely to defeat a poor warrior, just as in a
simulationist game. And while Hero Wars doesn't tell you as much about the
outcome as does RuneQuest, it's as detailed as Pendragon in this regard.
[Aside: Pendragon and Hero Wars are probably more accurate than RuneQuest,
Hero Wars also chooses a different world to model than does RuneQuest, a
Perhaps it would be better to call most games process-oriented and Hero
which has near-instant death from blood loss and no long-term effects from
most wounds.]
more literary (or adventure movie) view of Glorantha, but some
simulationist games do this too (Star Wars being a notable example).
Wars outcome-oriented, but I doubt this will happen.
Note that at no time did I use the word story. Nothing in Hero Wars says
One more comment: one problem with simulationist games is deciding on the
that you have to use the game system to tell a particular story. As Jeff
Richard's session at Glorantha-Con VII shows, it's just as easy to let the
characters change the story as with any game system.
level of detail. RuneQuest is fairly detailed. Pendragon is considerably
more abstract. Detailed systems are usually more complex and slow. Abstract
systems frequently lose accuracy. Hero Wars steps outside the decision of
where to draw the line by not simulating at all.
Lewis Jardine
> David Dunham is unsure about Vinga At the Hill of Gold:
>
> She does not appear in the orthadox Yelmalio version but:
Nor does she appear in the versions starring Vingkot, Halamalao, Heliakal,
Inora, or Zorak Zoran. Again, I refer you to Enclosure 2.
It's possible that Vinga is a bit player in the Vingkot version, but it
BTW, I believe red hair occurs naturally among most Wareran populations (we
seems to me that she is not part of this myth.
know it does in Pentans). I think Vinga happened to have red hair, there's
nothing mythical about it.
Simon Hibbs wondered of the Mostali:
> I wonder where they're makeing the plug for Magasta's Pool
No need, it already exists. After GC7, Greg mentioned they're planning a
huge engineering project in Jrustela to move it from its current location
to the whirlpool. Sure, there will be some disgruntled Storm Bulls in Prax,
but the Schedule is more important.
David Dunham <mailto:dunham@pensee.com>
Glorantha/RQ page: <http://www.pensee.com/dunham/glorantha.html>
Imagination is more important than knowledge. -- Albert Einstein
------------------------------
End of The Glorantha Digest V5 #649
***********************************
To unsubscribe from the Glorantha Digest, send an "unsubscribe"
command to glorantha-digest-request@chaosium.com. Glorantha is a
Trademark of Issaries Inc. With the exception of previously
copyrighted material, unless specified otherwise all text in this
digest is copyright by the author or authors, with rights granted to
copy for personal use, to excerpt in reviews and replies, and to
archive unchanged for electronic retrieval.
Official WWW at http://www.glorantha.com
Archives at http://rider.wharton.upenn.edu/~loren/rolegame.html
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.7 : Fri 13 Jun 2003 - 23:18:02 EEST