From: TTrotsky@aol.com
Date: Sun 21 Jun 1998 - 18:00:36 EEST
Alex:
<< Jeff Erwin:
I've been thinking about Hsunchen cults recently, and while I think the
<< -- while River Gods seem mostly interchangeable (and hence ultimately the
It depends what you mean by 'the same'. One could, I suppose, define two
> If Orlanth dies... his Runes, even the combination of those Runes, still
> exist. One can posit a hypothetical god for each combination of Runes, but
one
> should acknowledge that one set of runes can have more than one god as
well.
Peter Metcalfe constructed a rather nifty God Learner Fallacy from the former
proposition; I'm sure one could do much the same for the converse notion, and
suppose that some sort of Divine Pauli Exclusion Principle operates.
Counterexamples? Only "generic" deities a la GoG cookie-cutter River God,
City God, etc spring to mind, which could certainly be questioned>>
principle that all of them should have a different set of runes is a neat one,
it's difficult to put into practice. All Hsunchen cults should have a Beast
rune, and at most two others IMO (indeed, current examples have only one rune
besides Beast, unless you count the Chaos rune tagged onto Telmor in
historical time). Trying to come up with a different combination for every
Hsunchen race/cult isn't going to be easy, given that certain combinations
won't make sense and that many Hsunchen races are fairly similar to others -
there are at least three different types of cervine Hsunchen (Pralori, Damali
and Uncoling) and a fourth (Alekki) is quoted in some unofficial sources. OK,
so maybe it isn't *impossible* to give them all a unique set of runes that
make sense, but it'd be a stretch.
same, or related?)>>
gods with separate cults as being the same if they possess the same set of
runes and have other properties in common (e.g. both River Gods). But then the
argument becomes suspicously circular IMO.
Forward the glorious Red Army!
Trotsky
This is leaving aside the whole question, pan-Digest flamebait as it is,
of how univeral the idea of a fixed, given set of Runes is in any case...
Slainte,
Alex. >>
------------------------------
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.7 : Fri 13 Jun 2003 - 23:18:21 EEST