From: Matthew Thale (firstname.lastname@example.org)
Date: Thu 02 Mar 2000 - 03:14:46 EET
>>IMHO, infanticide is relatively common among the Praxians due to the
>>harsh living conditions under which they suffer. <snip>
Robert Stancliff responded:
> I have to voice strong disagreement to this concept. While it makes
>sense that Praxians are capable of abandoning infants, the harsh realities
>of life in Prax and the Wastes would preclude the need to do so.
> Far too many children will die from infant disease, animal and plant
>poisons, trampling and crushing accidents, falls, famine, collateral death
>during raids, and several other grisly ends, to ever need to intentionally
>kill a healthy, well formed child. Any child that can survive past the age
>of 8 is a blessing for the clan because they will probably survive to
>adulthood and are capable of performing useful work as they grow and train.
>The absense of children to raise is far more likely than too many children.
I find your argument to be very compelling. However, seeing that
infanticide occurs in similar societies in the RW, I believe that it
is practiced in Prax.
I cannot give you coherent arguments beyond that. The need for
infanticide is so alien to my comfortable style of living that I
cannot argue the reasons why is occurs in Prax.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.7 : Fri 13 Jun 2003 - 21:07:02 EEST