From: Alex Ferguson (abf@cs.ucc.ie)
Date: Fri 13 Oct 2000 - 20:28:07 EEST
David Dunham:
> Roderick Robertson wrote
>
> >What is the Sun on Earth? Apollo? A big ball of flaming gas? Ra? Mithras? El
> >Gabel? Sol Invictus?
>
> A better way to phrase this: is he Apollo or Helios?
Not necessarily better, but both seem to me to be "live" issues in
Glorantha. We have both "large scale disagreements" as to the nature
of the cosmos, and "small scale disagreements" as to whether to eat
bird on a Fireday, or whatever. I don't think either is terribly
easily to resolve in theory, but one way or another they seem to
be perfectly tractible in practice. IMC, the answer to questions
like "are the four (or so) major worldviews equally valid?" are in
effect either "No!" or "who cares?", depending in what respect you're
asking. Clearly I still have a meta-opinion about that (or twelve),
and equally, it might be of crucial imports to some games, I can see
that. As to more local-scale, endogenous disagreements, I may have
a greater or lesser 'working model' in mind as to what the 'underlying
reality' is, but I feel it's a rather in principle hard task to
put oneself in the position of, as part of running a once a week
roleplaying game, I shall undertake to know better than the fictional
people I'm "simulating", and have neat answers to the cosmological
questions they seek answers to for their entire lives, without
feeling I'm being limiting, prescriptive, and selling the entire
exercise short. Sure, it would equally be a cop-out to simply say,
"whatever story sounds good", or "the victory to those with the
mythic guns", but then again, I'm not advocating that, either.
Thomas McVey:
> and Hipparchus in 130 BC stopped all the fun by measuring the distance to
> the sun.
He did? I thought he was vague at best, the uncertainty on this topic
being a major difficulty in his measurement of the distance of the moon,
which he nevertheless got an excellent estimate of (in terms of earth
diameters, at least).
------------------------------
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.7 : Fri 13 Jun 2003 - 17:20:05 EEST